The Rectors of St. Mary's
Father Rick Robÿn, 12th Rector
- 1888-1891 The Rev. Vaughn Colston
- 1892-1894 The Rev. W. McCarthy Windsor
- 1894-1903 The Rev. George G. Merrill
- 1903-1911 The Rev. William Fitz-Simon
- 1911-1912 The Rev. Malbone Burkhead
- 1912-1937 The Rev. Robert S. W. Wood
- 1937-1952 The Rev. Leon E. Cartmell
- 1953-1969 The Rev. Fenimore E. Cooper
- 1969-1979 The Rev. James R. Leo
- 1980-2006 The Rev. Dr. Edwin H. Cromey
- 2007-2015 The Rev. Elizabeth S. McWhorter
- 2017-Present The Rev. Richard J. Robÿn